Half Moon Cay vs. Princess Cays: Which Private Island is Perfect for Your Cruise?

A private island stop is often the highlight of a Caribbean cruise, offering an exclusive escape with pristine beaches, crystal-clear waters, and top-tier amenities. Two of the most famous private islands in The Bahamas—Half Moon Cay and Princess Cays—are owned by Carnival Corporation but cater to different cruise lines. If you’re debating Half Moon Cay vs Princess Cays, this detailed comparison will help you decide which island best suits your cruising style.

Overview of the Islands

Half Moon Cay

Owned by Holland America Line and frequently visited by Carnival Cruise Line, Half Moon Cay is a 2,400-acre paradise with only 2% of the island developed. It is known for its unspoiled natural beauty, soft white sand, and shallow turquoise waters. The island offers a peaceful and relaxing atmosphere, perfect for travelers looking to unwind in a tropical setting.

Princess Cays

Princess Cays is a private beach resort located on the southern tip of Eleuthera Island, Bahamas. It is operated by Princess Cruises but also welcomes some Carnival Cruise Line ships. Unlike Half Moon Cay, Princess Cays is not a standalone island but a section of a larger island, offering a mix of local culture and exclusive resort-style amenities.

Comparing Half Moon Cay vs. Princess Cays

1. Beach Experience

• Half Moon Cay boasts a picture-perfect beach with powdery white sand and shallow, calm waters ideal for swimming and floating. Since the island is undeveloped except for guest areas, it feels more secluded and natural.
• Princess Cays, while also offering beautiful beaches, has a rockier shoreline in some areas. Beach shoes are recommended. However, it provides multiple designated beach areas with lounge chairs and cabanas, creating a more structured beach experience.

Top Pick: If you prioritize soft sand and crystal-clear water, Half Moon Cay takes the lead.

2. Water Activities & Excursions

• Half Moon Cay offers activities like kayaking, paddleboarding, and snorkeling. A highlight is the Stingray Adventure, where you can interact with these gentle sea creatures in a shallow lagoon.
• Princess Cays features snorkeling, paddleboarding, and jet skiing. The waters here are deeper than at Half Moon Cay, making it better suited for serious snorkelers and divers.

Top Pick: If you love shallow, calm waters for relaxation, Half Moon Cay is ideal. If you’re an adventurous snorkeler or jet skier, Princess Cays is a better choice.

3. Dining Options

• Half Moon Cay provides a buffet-style barbecue lunch included in your cruise fare, featuring grilled meats, tropical fruits, and salads. However, food options outside of this are limited.
• Princess Cays also includes a barbecue buffet, but guests can explore additional local flavors from vendors outside the designated cruise resort area.

Top Pick: If you want a more immersive food experience with local flavors, Princess Cays offers slightly more variety.

4. Private Cabanas & Lounging

• Half Moon Cay offers various private cabanas, villas, and even an exclusive overwater retreat called the Private Oasis, which accommodates larger groups with personal service.
• Princess Cays has private cabanas available for rent but lacks the ultra-luxurious options that Half Moon Cay provides.

Top Pick: Half Moon Cay wins for those looking for an exclusive luxury experience.

5. Shopping & Local Culture

• Half Moon Cay has limited shopping options, mostly selling souvenirs and basic beachwear.
• Princess Cays allows visitors to explore nearby Eleuthera, where they can purchase authentic Bahamian crafts, jewelry, and local products.

Top Pick: If shopping and cultural experiences matter to you, Princess Cays is the better option.

6. Family-Friendly vs. Adults-Only Appeal

• Half Moon Cay is family-friendly, offering a children’s water park and safe, shallow waters.
• Princess Cays is also family-friendly but has fewer kid-specific amenities.

Top Pick: Families with young children may prefer Half Moon Cay, while adults seeking a quiet escape might enjoy Princess Cays more.

Final Choice

• Choose Half Moon Cay if you want a more natural, tranquil island experience with soft sand, shallow waters, and luxury cabanas.
• Choose Princess Cays if you prefer a mix of relaxation, adventure, cultural experiences, and deeper waters for snorkeling.

Now that you know the differences between Princess Cays vs Half Moon Cay, it's time to book your ideal cruise vacation. Whether you're looking for a relaxing beach retreat at Half Moon Cay or an adventure-filled day at Princess Cays, CruiseBooking.com makes it easy to find and book the best cruise deals. Visit CruiseBooking.com today and plan your dream getaway!